The New Europe Arrives The Price of Civilizational Surrender France has given us a small domestic scene with the smell of a much larger historical defeat. Crowds storm a store. People shove, grab, drag appliances from shelves, fight over fans, push past each other as though the republic itself had been reduced to a discount aisle. The official story will be heat. The polite story will be “social tension.” The television story will be “consumer pressure during an extreme weather event.” The real story is uglier. Europe is beginning to discover what happens when a civilization loses control over its public reflexes. A fan is a modest object. A cheap machine with plastic blades and a short cord. In an orderly society, it is purchased. In a society entering a harder phase, it is seized. That is the whole difference between a country and a crowd. The scene in France matters because it shows, in miniature, a shift that European elites have spent decades denying. Western Europe is no lo...