Posts

Image
A Seat Without a Strategy Europe's Negotiating Problem The diplomatic week surrounding Ukraine, stretching from Abu Dhabi to Dublin, can be summarized through a single question: what exactly does Europe intend to do at the negotiating table? European governments have finally managed to secure a place in the process, having spent considerable time complaining that decisions about their future were being discussed without them. Yet the composition of the delegation they have assembled suggests that obtaining a chair may prove considerably easier than deciding what to say once seated. At the informal European Council meeting in Dublin on November 13, European leaders agreed that the continent would be represented by the European Union's institutions and five countries participating in the coalition of the willing: Britain, France, Germany, Italy, and Poland. António Costa assured everyone that this arrangement would allow Europe to speak with one clear and united voice. Such decla...
Image
The Art of Going Nowhere Abu Dhabi, the European Security Question, and the Diplomacy of Endless Negotiations Lao Tzu observed that the great Way is smooth, yet people prefer the side paths. Almost two and a half millennia later, the negotiations surrounding the Ukrainian conflict offer an interesting variation on this ancient observation. There are plenty of people walking, diplomatic activity is becoming increasingly energetic, and the number of participants wishing to join the procession continues to grow. The difficulty is that they are all heading toward rather different destinations. To some extent, the negotiating process has already acquired a life independent of its declared purpose. Meetings are organized, positions are synchronized, statements are issued, and new formats are proposed. Each participant has reasons to keep the machinery moving, even as the prospect of an actual settlement remains elusive. One suspects that the process has become so important partly becau...
Image
The Architecture of Exclusion Washington and Moscow Are Discussing Europe's Future. Brussels Has Other Ideas. Donald Trump has never been particularly modest in describing his diplomatic ambitions. His latest announcement promises a “great, beautiful deal” that would concern not merely Ukraine, but the whole of Europe. Given the current state of European affairs, the ambition is considerable. Whether the American president appreciates the full complexity of what he is proposing remains an interesting question, although his confidence in his ability to arrange things has rarely suffered from a shortage of supporting evidence. Jared Kushner, Trump's son-in-law and special envoy, has provided a more substantive explanation of the initiative. According to him, Washington seeks to develop practical mechanisms that account for the security interests of all parties, reduce the likelihood of future conflicts, and establish a more stable and predictable security environment. He id...
Image
The Progress Nobody Ordered When Silicon Valley’s Future Meets America’s Right to Say No The American midterm elections are being described as a “blue tsunami,” and the expression seems appropriate given the scale of the Democratic victory and the losses suffered by Republican candidates. Beneath the familiar electoral arithmetic, however, something considerably more interesting has taken place. For the first time, Americans have voted on a massive scale against the vision of the future being promoted by Silicon Valley, and the enormous financial resources of the technology industry proved remarkably ineffective in changing their minds. In political terms, the concept of progress championed by Elon Musk, Sam Altman, Peter Thiel, and their fellow architects of humanity’s technological destiny has suffered a crushing defeat. The American public has begun to question the assumption that every technological innovation automatically constitutes a public benefit, especially when its pr...
Image
Peace, Pending Approval The Harvest Cannot Wait A farmer planning next year’s harvest has a fairly modest list of requirements: fuel for the tractor, credit for seed, somewhere to store the crop, and a road along which to sell it. A family considering a return home has similarly practical concerns: a roof, electricity, a school, and some reason to believe that rebuilding a life is worth the effort. Eventually, every grand strategy has to find its way down to these questions. Martin Nissen, Germany’s agricultural attaché in Moscow from 2022 to 2025, approached the Ukrainian conflict with a title of unusual simplicity: Agriculture needs peace . According to Bild’ s account, his informal paper proposed placing contested territories under UN administration for five years, followed by referendums to determine their final status. The German Foreign Office explained that the initiative had been developed independently, without an official mandate. Boris Pistorius likewise described it as pri...